Now also available as
eBook
After neutrality and international enforcement, the next most valued feature
of international commercial arbitration is confidentiality. For reasons easy
to imagine, businessmen do not want their trade secrets, business plans,
strategies, contracts, financial results or any other types of business
information to be publicly accessible, as would commonly happen in court
proceedings. Yet the case law of arbitration shows that in practical terms
confidentiality is not to be taken for granted – in fact, it has become one of
the most undetermined matters in international arbitration. Although ‘the
emperor of arbitration may have clothes,’ as one scholar has quipped, his
raiments of secrecy can be ‘torn with surprising ease’.
This book deciphers the current degree of confidentiality in international
commercial arbitration as reflected by the most important arbitration rules,
national laws, other arbitration-related enactments, and practices of arbitral
tribunals and domestic courts globally. Drawing on this data and analysis, the
author then sets forth criteria to assess the breach of confidentiality in
international arbitration and the proper rules for protecting or sanctioning
such breaches.
What do we understand by confidentiality in arbitration? What are its
limitations? Who is bound to observe it? How can we quantify its breach? In
addressing these questions, the book engages such issues as the following:
-
reasons for disclosure – e.g., for the establishment of a defence, for the
enforcement of rights, in the public interest or in the interests of justice
-
disclosure by consent, express or implied;
-
circumstances triggering statutory obligation of disclosure;
-
recent trends towards greater transparency in investor-State arbitration;
-
court measures in support of arbitral confidentiality such as award of damages
for breach of confidentiality; and
-
categories of persons bound by confidentiality, including third parties such
as witnesses and experts.
Structured along the main stages of the arbitral process, the analysis covers
the duty of confidentiality from the initiation of arbitral proceedings
through their unfolding to the issuance of the award and after. The scope of
confidentiality is reviewed in the practice of arbitral tribunals and domestic
courts, and from the perspective of international arbitration institutions,
with detailed attention to various arbitration rules and numerous significant
cases.
In its elucidation of the amount of confidentiality that ‘veils’ each phase of
the arbitral process, and its ground-breaking identification of ‘patterns of
disclosure’, this book is sure to raise awareness about the various facets and
problems posed by confidentiality in arbitration. Although its scholarly
contribution to the law of international commercial arbitration cannot be
gainsaid, corporate counsel worldwide will quickly prize its more practical
value.
Foreword
Preface
Acknowledgments
Introduction
Chapter 1 Distinguishing Confidentiality from Privacy: A Possible
Definition
Chapter 2 The Legal Basis of Confidentiality
Chapter 3 The Scope of the Duty to Maintain Confidentiality
Chapter 4 Actors Bound by the Duty to Maintain Confidentiality
Chapter 4 Actors Bound by the Duty to Maintain Confidentiality
Chapter 5 Breach of Confidentiality and Its Consequences
Conclusion
Bibliography
Table of Cases
Selected Arbitration Instruments
Index