National practice, law, and jurisprudence on state aid are developing
rapidly in the present context of EU decentralization. Although the EU rules
governing state aid are widely discussed, there has been until now a dearth of
practice-oriented material on the actual implementation of these rules at the
national level. This important contribution to the ongoing debate on the
reform of the state aid system addresses for the first time the full scale of
procedural questions arising in the implementation of EU state aid law. It
covers all issues, ranging from the intention to grant an aid via judicial
protection for competitors right through to recovery of aid and judicial
protection of the beneficiary. The book presents the documentation on state
aid which was made available to the participants of the 22nd World Congress of
the Fédération Internationale de Droit Européenne (FIDE) at Cyprus in November
2006. Detailed reports by well-known practitioners or professors of law
discuss and analyze the implementation of EU State aid law in 17 EU Member
States, as well as Norway, Switzerland, and Croatia. The national reports,
based on a standard questionnaire, are preceded by an analytical general
report, comparing and assessing results of the analysis of Member States’ law
in the light of Community law, and an EU report on state aid procedures.
Issues addressed include the following:
• transparency obligations;
• ensuring compliance with the notification obligation;
• ensuring the compatibility of aid and the application of block exemptions;
• recovery of aid;
• limitation of judicial review; and
• the position of state aid debt in bankruptcy proceedings.
No serious academic contribution to the present debate on the reform of state
aid law can afford to ignore this book. As a unique and thorough overview of
state-of-the-art knowledge on national law and practice on EU State aid
matters, this compendium will be of inestimable value to practitioners
involved in representing interests of beneficiaries and competitors before
national authorities or national courts, or before the European Commission or
European Courts. The analyses will also be welcomed by authorities granting
state aid, including public enterprises.
Contents: Introduction. General Report on State Aid; P.F. Nemitz.
State Aid—The Effective Application of EU State Aid Procedures: From a Plan to
Grant Aid to the Recovery of Illegal Aid—The Role of National Law and Practice;
F.-E. González Díaz. Austria; A. Lengauer. Belgium;
J. Derenne, C. Guirado. Croatia; M. Liszt, S. Petrović.
Cyprus; C. Lycourgos. Denmark; P. Biering, K. Lundgaard
Hansen. Finland; H. Merikalla. France; A. Müller-Rappard, J.
Bousin, J. Derenne. Germany; J. Kühling. Greece; A. Metaxas.
Ireland; A.M. Collins, D. Collins. Italy; C. Schepisi. Latvia;
E. Šķibele, A. Vītols. The Netherlands; P.C.
Adriaanse. Norway; E. Hjelmeng. Poland; S. Dudzik. Portugal;
M. Porto, J. Nogueira de Almeida. Spain; J L. Buendia Sierra.
Sweden; I. Simonsson. Switzerland; P. Këllezi. United
Kingdom; A. Sutton.